The Cleveland Browns face one of the most challenging quarterback dilemmas in the NFL this offseason. Deshaun Watson has proven to be a poor fit, and while reports suggest he’ll return for 2025, the team is stuck with limited options for moving on. Cutting Watson outright seems implausible due to his massive contract, yet keeping him on the roster presents issues for both team morale and performance.
Finding his replacement only adds to the complexity. The Browns boast elite talent in players like Myles Garrett, Denzel Ward, and Joel Bitonio, all performing at All-Pro levels despite the team’s disappointing 3-10 record. With these stars under contract for 2025, the front office must urgently find a quarterback solution to avoid wasting another year of their prime.
Potential QB Solutions
1. Veteran Bridge Quarterback
The Browns might explore a short-term fix with a veteran signing. Jameis Winston, currently benched, could be a floor option to hold the position for one or two seasons. However, this wouldn’t excite fans or inspire much confidence for immediate contention.
2. Draft Prospects
Cleveland’s current draft position at eighth overall likely puts them out of reach for top prospects like Shedeur Sanders or Cam Ward. Even if available, there’s debate over whether these players are ready to start as rookies. A later-round sleeper like Notre Dame’s Riley Leonard could be a developmental option, but that wouldn’t solve the team’s immediate needs.
3. Trade Market
A wildcard solution could emerge from Minnesota. With Sam Darnold reviving his career and entering the MVP conversation, he’ll likely seek a long-term contract after leading the Vikings on a playoff run. Meanwhile, rookie J.J. McCarthy, drafted 10th overall, remains sidelined due to a preseason knee injury but showed promise in training camp.
The Minnesota Connection
Darnold’s resurgence under Kevin O’Connell has made him a valuable asset, but retaining both Darnold and McCarthy might create unnecessary tension in the Vikings’ quarterback room. If Minnesota commits to Darnold long-term, McCarthy could become a prime trade candidate. His potential upside, combined with Minnesota’s need to maximize their roster with additional assets, makes him an intriguing option for quarterback-needy teams like Cleveland.
The Browns could make an aggressive move for McCarthy, offering the Vikings valuable draft capital to pry him away. This would allow Minnesota to strengthen other areas while providing Cleveland with a young quarterback with starter potential.
The Stakes
Regardless of the route they take, the Browns must address their quarterback position decisively. With a talented core ready to win now, they can’t afford another wasted season. Whether through a veteran bridge, a trade for a promising talent like McCarthy, or a bold draft move, Cleveland’s offseason decisions will shape their immediate future—and potentially define their franchise trajectory for years to come.
